Healthcare professions have called for medical records to be exempt from legislation intended to increase the government's powers for accessing and sharing UK citizens' personal data.
In an open joint letter, eight organisations - including the British Medical Association (BMA), the Royal College of General Practitioners, the Royal College of Surgeons, and the Royal College of Nursing - raised their concerns with Justice Secretary Jack Straw about proposals in the Coroners and Justice Bill.
The letter expressed "grave concerns" about Clause 152 of the bill which, in its current form, appears to grant the government unprecedented powers to access people's confidential medical records and share them with third parties.
The organisations warned that this would "undermine the presumption of confidentiality, corrode trust in the doctor-patient relationship and could have a disastrous impact on both the health of individuals and the public".
Dr Hamish Meldrum, chairman of the BMA Council, stated: "The doctor-patient relationship is based on trust. If patients cannot be 100 per cent sure that their records are confidential, they will inevitably be reluctant to share vital information with their doctor."
Meldrum did add, however, that Straw has indicated he might be willing to amend the legislation to protect a person's right to confidentiality.
"We welcome the fact that he is taking people's concerns on board, and hope he will provide assurances that confidential health information will be exempt," he said.
The letter, which requests a meeting with Straw, also raised concerns about the potential impact on broader health policy issues that could undermine public confidence in the National Health Service (NHS) Care Records Service.
It pointed out that, as currently drafted, there was nothing in the bill to prevent the government overturning the confidentiality clauses of the Human Fertility and Embryology Act or even of the Venereal Disease Regulations.
"In our view, the proposals will also be in violation of Article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR)," stated the letter.
These organisations have joined the growing chorus of objections to the data sharing implications of the bill, which have been led by the Information Commissioner's Office.
-
Cisco names Oliver Tuszik as global sales chiefNews Cisco has announced the appointment of Oliver Tuszik as its new executive vice president of global sales, who replaces Gary Steele.
-
AI will chew through the same amount of energy as Japan by 2030News The energy demand of AI data centers will top that of Japan by the end of the decade, new research shows – and that’s providing that energy grids can even keep up.
-
ICO admits it's too slow dealing with complaints – so it's eying up automation to cut staff workloadsNews The UK's data protection authority has apologized for being slow to respond to data protection complaints, saying it's been overwhelmed by increased workloads.
-
“Limited resources” scupper ICO probe into EasyJet breachNews The decision to drop the probe has been described as “deeply concerning” by security practitioners
-
Surge in workplace monitoring prompts new ICO guidelines on employee privacyNews Detailed guidance on how to implement workplace monitoring could prevent data protection blunders
-
TikTok could be hit with £27m fine for failing to protect children's privacyNews Social media firm issued with a notice from the ICO for potential violations of UK data protection laws
-
What is AdTech and why is it at the heart of a regulation storm?In-depth The UK data regulator has come under heavy fire for consistently delaying much-needed action, privacy groups say
-
ICO crackdown on AI recruitment part of three-year vision to save businesses £100 millionNews ICO25 outlines a fresh approach that involves releasing learning materials, advice, and a new ICO-moderated discussion forum for businesses
-
Clearview AI fined £7.5m over improper use of UK dataNews Australian facial recognition firm collected 20 billion images from the internet without consent in order to build its database
-
UK data watchdog cut IT spending by £1.2 million during pandemicNews The ICO’s IT budget has been slashed by around 23% since 2019
