Despite the new information, and accusations that the secret trials broke RIPA, the ICO opted not to investigate further.
Taking it legal
But that didn't stop the EU started asking questions about whether the UK should have allowed the trials, sending a formal letter to the government in August 2008. The government's response a month later backed an opt-in Phorm, saying it was keeping an eye on the system, which kept the EU quiet - at the time, anyway.
The EU wasn't the only authority questioning the legality of Phorm. In September, the City of London Police paid a visit to BT, asking questions regarding the trial, but eventually decided it wasn't up to them.
Amidst this, BT launched the third trial, which asked 10,000 users if they wanted to take part.
In December of 2008, just a few months after the test, BT said it still expected to roll out the technology but not before banning talk about Webwise on its own forums.
That month also saw Phorm lose three board members and its chief operating officer but it managed to gain former Chancellor Norman Lamont and former Ofcom board member Kip Meek to its lineup. A few weeks later, firm lost two more executives, so the new year signalled a fresh start in a few ways for Phorm.
The boycotts
This spring, the Open Rights Group (ORG) kicked things off sort of with the publication of an open letter well, it would be open, wouldn't it? to a host of top tech firms, asking them to boycott the service.
It was targeted at Microsoft, Google/YouTube, Facebook, AOL/Bebo, Yahoo, Amazon and eBay. If the letter met its objective and those firms did boycott Phorm, it would effectively be out of business, as those sites make up a huge percentage of UK web traffic.
The Guardian kicked things off, pulling out of plans to use Phorm on its site in March of this year.
A few weeks later, and not specifically in response to the ORG letter, Amazon asked Phorm not to scan traffic from its site although Phorm has admitted it is trying to win back the giant online retailer.
Amazon's move was echoed days later by Wikipedia, which shortly thereafter also blocked Phorm, saying: "we consider the scanning and profiling of our visitors' behavior by a third party to be an infringement on their privacy."
Dragging the government in
In the midst of all this, the European Union took legal action against the UK over the BT trials of Phorm.
"Technologies like internet behavioural advertising can be useful for businesses and consumers but they must be used in a way that complies with EU rules. These rules are there to protect the privacy of citizens and must be rigorously enforced by all Member States," said EU telecoms commissioner Viviane Reding, in a statement.
Phorm noted that the issue is clearly between the UK and the EU, but stressed that its services are "fully compliant with UK legislation and relevant EU directives".
The UK has until the middle of this month to respond to the legal case.
-
Cleo attack victim list grows as Hertz confirms customer data stolenNews Hertz has confirmed it suffered a data breach as a result of the Cleo zero-day vulnerability in late 2024, with the car rental giant warning that customer data was stolen.
-
Lateral moves in tech: Why leaders should support employee mobilityIn-depth Encouraging staff to switch roles can have long-term benefits for skills in the tech sector
-
Modern enterprise cybersecuritywhitepaper Cultivating resilience with reduced detection and response times
-
IDC InfoBrief: How CIOs can achieve the promised benefits of sustainabilitywhitepaper CIOs are facing two conflicting strategic imperatives
-
Where will AI take security, and are we ready?whitepaper Steer through the risks and capitalise on the benefits of AI in cyber security
-
Does your security strategy show continuous improvement?Sponsored Content It’s important to do a regular check-up on your security systems and look at how you can implement continuous improvement as part of your security strategy
-
Protecting your cloud from malicious actorsSPONSORED In today’s multi-cloud world, there are more attack surfaces than ever for hackers to target - here’s what you can do to protect your business
-
The threats targeting operational technology and how to beat themSPONSORED Attackers looking to exploit overlooked flaws in OT or infect networks laterally can only be stopped with comprehensive observability strategies
-
What makes a satisfied customer?Sponsored Round-the-clock customer support could be the difference between success and failure in the event of IT disruption
-
Take your business further with a dedicated internet connectionwhitepaper Achieve internet speed and reliability to match your business ambitions
