Mobiles on the tube: Move down the carriage or stand clear?
With a deal to get mobile connectivity on the tube coming closer and closer, we ask whether a good service on all London Underground lines is what commuters really want.


ANALYSIS: Rumours have been rife this week that London is getting increasingly close to mobile access for voice and data on the Underground.
Both the current mayor, Boris Johnson, and his predecessor, Ken Livingstone, have examined the possibility and pushed to get operators and equipment manufacturers on board with the scheme.
However, previous attempts fell down the proverbial escalator before moving from theory to reality.
It has now been reported widely Huawei will take up the cause by providing the hardware for Transport for London (TfL), with Thales installing the network and various UK operators taking care of connectivity.
But will Johnson's hopes for mobile access on the tube by 2012 remove the barriers to working on the go or just cause more infuriating delays on an already overcrowded network?
Barking mad?
City Hall might be behind the idea of mobile access underground but it seems the public who use the transport services feel quite differently about the whole thing.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Following the rumours, GoodMobilePhones.co.uk carried out a poll to see if Londoners were positive about the idea but feedback could have Huawei worried.
More than three-quarters (76 per cent) of the 1,000-plus London residents over the age of 18 surveyed said they weren't in favour of mobile connectivity on the underground and a raft of reasons flowed from the commuters.
Top of the list was an assumed higher risk of mugging, with 31 per cent using this as their justification. A baffling 16 per cent had concerns it would increase their monthly bills, whereas an understandable 14 per cent said they just didn't want to have to listen to other people chatting on their mobiles.
"The news of the underground mobile network certainly has caused quite a stir, but I am surprised to see so many people are against it," said Mark Owen, GoodMobilePhones.co.uk's founder.
"There are obviously risks with having increased usage of mobile phones on the tube, but these are things that can be sorted. Having an underground mobile phone network is the next logical step, following in the footsteps of Paris and Hong Kong, who have had no major problems."
Jennifer Scott is a former freelance journalist and currently political reporter for Sky News. She has a varied writing history, having started her career at Dennis Publishing, working in various roles across its business technology titles, including ITPro. Jennifer has specialised in a number of areas over the years and has produced a wealth of content for ITPro, focusing largely on data storage, networking, cloud computing, and telecommunications.
Most recently Jennifer has turned her skills to the political sphere and broadcast journalism, where she has worked for the BBC as a political reporter, before moving to Sky News.
-
Should AI PCs be part of your next hardware refresh?
AI PCs are fast becoming a business staple and a surefire way to future-proof your business
By Bobby Hellard
-
Westcon-Comstor and Vectra AI launch brace of new channel initiatives
News Westcon-Comstor and Vectra AI have announced the launch of two new channel growth initiatives focused on the managed security service provider (MSSP) space and AWS Marketplace.
By Daniel Todd
-
This live map of every London Underground tube train will make you appreciate open data
News The mesmerising project wouldn’t be possible without TfL’s open API
By Adam Shepherd
-
Uber's top UK exec quits
News Jo Bertram leaves for new role, but says "current challenges" mean a change of face is necessary
By Nicole Kobie
-
TfL passes 1 billion contactless journeys
News Almost half of pay as you go users are opting to pay via contactless technology
By Clare Hopping
-
TfL hopes to ease traffic with crowdsourced data
News The organisation has teamed up with Waze to offer real-time information about traffic congestion
By Clare Hopping
-
TfL implements e-paper bus stop signage
News The signs will show real-time scheduling of buses rather than the digital info seen on some stops
By Clare Hopping
-
TfL pays Atos £6m as part of move to a SIAM model
News Transport body impressed with outsourcer’s experience in handling service desk operations
By Joe Curtis
-
Amazon teams up with Post Office for online deliveries
News Argos also bringing click and collect to underground stations
By Rene Millman
-
TfL brings contactless payments to London's tube network
News Following trials on buses, you can now use your contactless payment cards on London Underground and Overground lines
By Clare Hopping