Two Government mobile rollouts for police have been criticised for not providing enough benefits to the majority of forces in the UK.
The central issue the National Audit Office (NAO) had with the Mobile Information Programme, which provided devices including BlackBerrys to officers, was that it failed to do more than let officers spend more time out of the station.
Although the project was achieved at a "reasonable cost," the benefits have not been enough to justify the 80 million spent, the NAO said.
It did not consider adequately how forces would use mobile technology.
Only 10 of 32 forces responding to an NAO survey said they had seen some for of cashable savings from the Mobile Information Programme, and even then it was a small amount.
"The business case for the Mobile Information Programme was constructed around the delivery of mobile devices and therefore considered a narrow range of implementation options," the NAO report read.
"It did not consider adequately how forces would use mobile technology, the amount of local expenditure required or the realism of the announced deadlines."
The NAO also claimed the project did not assess how many devices would be need for each force, nor was funding adequately split between different forces.
"The proportion of devices procured by forces we surveyed ranged from a device available to one per cent of police officers and police community support officers to 151 per cent. Three forces have more devices than officers as they are used by civilian police staff," the report added.
"However, some nineteen forces have sufficient devices available for less than half of their officers. This has restricted how far these forces can reduce bureaucracy through improving processes and subsequently reducing the cost of back-office functions."
Furthermore, the MobileID scheme, which was designed to bring fingerprint checking functionality to devices, had not successfully achieved its aims.
Despite the criticisms, the NAO said the programme had increased the visibility of police and officers do spend more time out of the station. Furthermore, some of the forces surveyed said they expected to make more savings as a result of the project in the future.
-
Third time lucky? Microsoft finally begins roll-out of controversial Recall featureNews The Windows Recall feature has been plagued by setbacks and backlash from security professionals
-
The UK government wants quantum technology out of the lab and in the hands of enterprisesNews The UK government has unveiled plans to invest £121 million in quantum computing projects in an effort to drive real-world applications and adoption rates.
-
Trade body urges UK government to speed up National Semiconductor StrategyNews Trade body techUK has urged the UK government to accelerate the implementation of the National Semiconductor Strategy.
-
Blackberry revenue falls by 4% as cyber security division takes hitNews Despite this, the company’s Internet of Things (IoT) division increased its revenue by 28% as it attracted new customers from the automotive sector
-
BlackBerry revival is officially dead as OnwardMobility shuts downNews The Texas-based startup is mysteriously shutting down and taking its ultra-secure 5G BlackBerry with it
-
US lawmakers call for restrictions on software exports to Chinese chip companiesNews US government needs broader, systemic restrictions to avoid Chinese military innovation, says letter
-
BlackBerry and AWS are developing a standardized vehicle data platformNews Platform will give automakers a standardized way to process data from vehicle sensors in the cloud
-
BlackBerry thwarts mobile phishing attacks with new AI toolsNews The company's Protect Mobile platform alerts users to potential malware before a link is clicked
-
BlackBerry Persona Desktop delivers zero-trust security at the endpointNews New security solution learns user behavior and can take action if there’s an abnormality
-
A 5G BlackBerry phone with physical keyboard is coming in 2021News The business phone to be resurrected with OnwardMobility and FIH Mobile planning a security-savvy enterprise handset
