Samsung's flagship Galaxy smartphone looks very similar to Apple's iPhone, but the South Korean firm has not violated the iPhone design, a Seoul court has ruled.
The South Korean ruling comes as the two technology titans are locked in a high-stakes global patent battle that mirrors a fierce rivalry for industry supremacy between two companies that control more than half the world's smartphone sales.
The two products have a different look.
The Seoul court ruling on Friday comes ahead of more crucial US verdicts. Nine jurors began deliberation on Wednesday in California in one of many disputes between the two firms around the world that analysts see as partly aimed at curbing the spread of Google's Android, the world's most used mobile software.
"There are lots of external design similarities between the iPhone and Galaxy S, such as rounded corners and large screens ... but these similarities had been documented in previous products," a judge at the Seoul Central District Court said on Friday.
"Given that it's very limited to make big design changes in touch-screen based mobile products in general ... and the defendant (Samsung) differentiated its products with three buttons in the front and adopted different designs in camera and (on the) side, the two products have a different look," the judge said.
The judge said it was difficult to say that consumers would confuse the iPhone with the Galaxy given they clearly have the respective company logos on the back of each model, and consumers also factor in operating systems, brand, applications, price, and services when buying a phone.
The judge ordered Samsung to immediately stop selling 10 products, including the Galaxy S II, and also banned sales of four Apple products, including the iPhone 4 and iPad 2.
The court ruled that Apple infringed on two of Samsung's wireless technology patents and was ordered to pay Samsung 40 million won ($35,400). Samsung was fined 25 million won for violating one patent relating to so-called bouncing-back function used when scrolling electronic documents.
The compensation sought by both Apple and Samsung in South Korea is small due to the relatively small size of the market.
The wrangle was triggered by Apple's lawsuit in April last year claiming Samsung slavishly copied Apple's smartphones and tablets. Samsung has countered that it simply developed its own "unique" products in a bid to "best the competition," and that Apple actually owes money for using its patented technology.
In the United States, Apple is demanding more than $2.5 billion in damages and an order to permanently ban Samsung from selling patent-infringing products. Samsung argues Apple owes $422 million for violating a clutch of its patents.
Neither Apple nor Samsung had an immediate comment on the Seoul ruling.
-
Should AI PCs be part of your next hardware refresh?AI PCs are fast becoming a business staple and a surefire way to future-proof your business
-
Westcon-Comstor and Vectra AI launch brace of new channel initiativesNews Westcon-Comstor and Vectra AI have announced the launch of two new channel growth initiatives focused on the managed security service provider (MSSP) space and AWS Marketplace.
-
Samsung ramps up AI capabilities with Oxford Semantic Technologies acquisitionNews Oxford Semantic Technologies' knowledge graph tech will be incorporated into Samsung products across the board
-
Samsung UK recruits its first chief customer officer in bid to boost partner engagementNews Deborah Honig will lead Samsung UK’s customer experience activity across its portfolio of business offerings in the region
-
Samsung proposes 11 Texas semiconductor plants worth $191 billionNews The school boards of Austin and Taylor are to consider new facilities that could bring 10,000 new jobs to the area
-
Apple patents a computer inside a keyboardNews Device could enable clutter-free ultra-portability, says document
-
Samsung heir apologizes, promises he won’t pass company control to childrenNews Jay Y. Lee makes a rare apology in his first media appearance in five years
-
Samsung DeX Pad hands-on: Turn your Galaxy S9 into your desktopFirst look Samsung gives its thin-client solution a flawed but promising update
-
From startup to scaleup: How mentoring can make a success out of your businessSponsored We join SPIXII three months into Samsung’s mentorship programme to see just how the company has grown
-
How technology gives you the freedom to explore new ideasIn-depth Sometimes all it takes is a shift of focus to make a company successful, thankfully mobile tech makes it possible
