Privacy expert orders Facebook to make Social Graph easier to opt-out of
Despite social networking giant's data protection assurances, industry watcher wants firm to offer users more help in hiding their data.

Social networking giant Facebook has been urged to make it easier for users to opt-out of having their data used to generate results for its new Graph Search service.
The firm took the wraps off the beta version of its new search offering earlier this week, which aims to make it easier for users to delve into their friends' interests, checked-in places and photos.
During the launch event, Facebook chief Mark Zuckerberg said the firm had gone to great lengths to ensure its new offering is "privacy aware" through the rollout of new data protection tools.
The system should be opt-out by default and if users wish to be included they should opt-in.
These include the introduction of Privacy Shortcuts, which allow users to clearly see who can view their content and contact them on the site, and a new mass untag tool.
The latter lets users disassociate themselves from multiple pictures or posts they would rather not be tagged in.
Furthermore, Zuckerberg said, as Graph Search is rolled out across the firm's user base, Facebook members will receive a prompt on the homepage telling them to review the data they have on show.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Industry feedback
Despite the introduction of these measures, concerns about how the new service may infringe on users' privacy have still been raised.
Eden Zoller, principal analyst at market watcher Ovum, said, despite Facebook's reassurances, users will need to keep their guard up.
"[Facebook] claims to have built Graph Search with privacy in mind, but Facebook has a mixed track record on this front and is in the habit of pushing privacy to the limits of what is acceptable," said Zoller.
Meanwhile, independent privacy expert, Alexander Hanff, said Facebook users should have the right to opt-in if they want their information shared via Graph Search.
"It is my belief that the system should be opt-out by default and if users wish to be included they should opt-in," Hanff told IT Pro.
"Since users never submitted their data for the purpose of Facebook creating and monitising search, it is questionable whether or not the move is compliant with the Data Protection Act," he added.
He also suggested Facebook should directly point users to the privacy settings they need to adjust to opt-out of Graph Search.
"[This should include] text overlays explaining exactly what to change and how to change it," he advised. "Anything less is completely unacceptable."
In a statement to IT Pro, Facebook said, while there is no way for users to completely opt out of Graph Search, they can easily control the amount of data featured about them.
"We think it will take time for our users to understand the full potential of Graph Search," said the statement.
"We are going to be working hard to make sure there is plenty of information available from new user education, in-product education, and...our recently announced privacy tools to help users control what they share and find the best way to use the new product," it added.
-
Why are many men in tech blind to the gender divide?
In-depth From bias to better recognition, male allies in tech must challenge the status quo to advance gender equality
By Keri Allan
-
BenQ PD3226G monitor review
Reviews This 32-inch monitor aims to provide the best of all possible worlds – 4K resolution, 144Hz refresh rate and pro-class color accuracy – and it mostly succeeds
By Sasha Muller
-
Meta to pay $725 million in Cambridge Analytica lawsuit settlement
News The settlement closes the long-running lawsuit into how Facebook's owner, Meta, handled the Cambridge Analytica scandal
By Ross Kelly
-
Meta's earnings are 'cause for concern' and 2023 looks even bleaker
Analysis Calls for investor faith in metaverse tech only emphasise the worries that its investment strategy won't pay off
By Rory Bathgate
-
Microsoft and Meta announce integration deal between Teams and Workplace
News Features from both business collaboration platforms will be available to users without having to switch apps
By Connor Jones
-
Facebook is shutting down its controversial facial recognition system
News The move will see more than a billion facial templates removed from Facebook's records amid a push for more private applications of the technology
By Connor Jones
-
'Changing name to Meat': Industry reacts to Facebook's Meta rebrand
News The rebrand attempts to provide a clearer distinction between Facebook and its umbrella company
By Connor Jones
-
Facebook's Oversight Board demands more transparency
News Board bashed the social media giant for its preferential treatment of certain high-profile accounts
By Danny Bradbury
-
Facebook claims AI managed to reduce hate speech by 50%
News The social media platform has hit back at claims the tech it uses to fight hate speech is inadequate
By Sabina Weston
-
Facebook to hire 10,000 workers across the EU
News The high-skilled jobs drive is a “vote of confidence” in the European tech industry
By Jane McCallion