This female startup invented a fake male CEO to expose the sexism of business
Witchsy invented a fake male CEO, and instantly noticed things getting easier

I have something that gives me an inherent advantage in the world of technology, and sadly it's nothing to do with aptitude. It's that handy Y chromosome which gives me a whole series of invisible advantages from being higher on the pay scale to being given unfair deference in meetings. A gentleman may indeed make his own luck, but his biological roll of the dice should certainly be credited with an assist.
The key word there, of course, is "invisible". Although my beard and 6ft 4in frame may make my gender instantly apparent, there are plenty who believe that the playing field is entirely equal for men and women. To those people, here's an interesting case study to chew over, concerning Witchsy an online marketplace for art that doesn't fit in with Etsy's saccharine flavour of whimsy.
As explained to Fast Company, the company founders Penelope Gazin and Kate Dwyer discovered that the men they found themselves dealing with as they tried to get their business off the ground were pretty trying: terse and condescending, one developer even tried to stealthily delete code from the website when Gazin turned him down for a date.
This is when Gazin and Dwyer decided to hire a man: Keith Mann to be precise. Only Keith was purely fictional: an imaginary CEO hidden behind a wall of email text to placate their sexist business partners. "It was like night and day," explained Dwyer. "It would take me days to get a response, but Keith could not only get a response and a status update, but also be asked if he wanted anything else or if there was anything else that Keith needed help with."
"I think we could have gotten pretty bent out of shape about that," Dwyer continued. "Wow, are people really going to talk to this imaginary man with more respect than us? But we were like, you know what, this is clearly just part of this world that we're in right now. We want this and want to make this happen."
And they have. In its first year, Witchsy has turned over around $200,000 worth of art, giving content creators 80% of every transaction. The result is the Keith Mann has stepped down from the day-to-day fake running of the business to spend more time, no doubt, on the fake golf course.
The phenomenon of men being taken more seriously than women in business especially technology is not a new one. Indeed, a 2006 study discovered that women are more likely to moderate the way they write emails so as to be seen as friendly, rather than awkward. This fascinatingly depressing Twitter Moment demonstrates what happens when men and women accidentally swap email signatures.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
After a false career start producing flash games, Alan Martin has been writing about phones, wearables and internet culture for over a decade with bylines all over the web and print.
Previously Deputy Editor of Alphr, he turned freelance in 2018 and his words can now be found all over the web, on the likes of Tom's Guide, The i, TechRadar, NME, Gizmodo, Coach, T3, The New Statesman and ShortList, as well as in the odd magazine and newspaper.
He's rarely seen not wearing at least one smartwatch, can talk your ear off about political biographies, and is a long-suffering fan of Derby County FC (which, on balance, he'd rather not talk about). He lives in London, right at the bottom of the Northern Line, long after you think it ends.
You can find Alan tweeting at @alan_p_martin, or email him at mralanpmartin@gmail.com.
-
Cleo attack victim list grows as Hertz confirms customer data stolen
News Hertz has confirmed it suffered a data breach as a result of the Cleo zero-day vulnerability in late 2024, with the car rental giant warning that customer data was stolen.
By Ross Kelly
-
Lateral moves in tech: Why leaders should support employee mobility
In-depth Encouraging staff to switch roles can have long-term benefits for skills in the tech sector
By Keri Allan
-
It’s the end of the road for Women Who Code, following loss of “critical” funding
News The organization supporting women in the tech industry is being dissolved 13 years after it was founded
By Emma Woollacott
-
Five common barriers holding back women in tech
Women in tech still face significant challenges in the workplace
By Keri Allan
-
Report: Brexit and COVID to blame for lack of diversity in tech
News One in two surveyed respondents cited the two events as key factors in the failure to improve diversity in leadership roles
By Sabina Weston
-
IT Pro Panel: Tackling technical recruitment
IT Pro Panel With the recruitment market shifting, how can businesses both retain their best staff and fill gaping talent shortages?
By Adam Shepherd
-
Australia allocates $6.7 million to advance women in STEM initiatives
News Women make up only 28% of the country's STEM workers
By Zach Marzouk
-
IT Pro Panel: What’s stopping diversity in tech?
IT Pro Panel The need for more diversity is well established - but we still have a way to go
By Adam Shepherd
-
Podcast transcript: Why techies shouldn’t become managers
IT Pro Podcast Read the full transcript for this episode of the IT Pro Podcast
By IT Pro
-
The IT Pro Podcast: Why techies shouldn’t become managers
IT Pro Podcast Managing people is a completely different skillset to managing technology - so why do we keep pushing people from one to the other?
By IT Pro