Why good deals go wrong

handshake torn

Some channel deals are memorable for all the wrong reasons, and the flaws are often related to a failure to forge strong working partner relationships that deliver the best customer solutions – as several partners have revealed to Channel Pro.

Partnership problems can often be spotted early on and are likelier with multi-tier, multi-partner channels, according to Ian Moyse, chief revenue officer at sales software provider OneUp Sales and a 30-year veteran of the IT channel.

The most difficult deals can also seem too easy to begin with.

"Sometimes they tell you confidently that they just want to buy X. It can be a hard one to throw that back and ask: 'Are you sure?'," he says.

"So you think you need to do this thing, and you do it. But that's just your interpretation. You've asked certain questions and come up with this assimilation. It's like a doctor prescribing medicine when they haven't seen the patient. How do you know it's the right thing?"

Moyse says miscommunication can then get worse the further away partners are from the vendor, making for potential misunderstandings about the nature of the relationship and the solution. The customer then becomes frustrated as they’re not sure who to blame for what’s gone wrong, while IT providers can end up providing additional commercial, technical or other special resources to support a deal.

Additionally, sales professionals can be tempted to oversell – positioning their company or partner solution as the definitive answer. Sometimes, this might be because the partner simply hasn't stuck around long enough post-implementation to find out whether a solution really delivers.

If you're not speaking directly with the end client yourself, things can turn sour fast, he confirms.

If you're serious about growing your MSP, then you first need to focus on building a top-performing sales team. Sales experts share their advice in this free guide.

Download now

"Get on the phone together and work it out," says Moyse. "Be on those first calls together too. Don't assume you know everything and don't guess."

Kevin Eley, UK and Europe vice president of sales at security platform vendor LogRhythm, similarly finds that the most difficult deals stem from multilateral, complex relationships. Miscommunication in the procurement process especially can catch channel partners out.

"Once we were told that the organisation in question had appointed a third-party procurement agency to run a 'very robust and tightly managed, highly scrutinised request for information (RFI)/ request for proposal (RFP) process'," Eley reveals.

Eley recalls that the team did not know if this agency had ever been involved in similar solution discovery or design, or cybersecurity functions. Despite doubts, they decided to proceed.

"Our team had really constructive discussions, directly with the expected users. We felt that we were building rapport, and were a good fit," he says. "We won the deal, and felt good about that until about a week later."

They were then told by the third-party agency that an unnamed organisation had contested the outcome, looking at the procurement process, and decided to rerun the entire process again. This obviously increased the resource outlay, with a knock-on impact on the actual project after winning both requests for proposal.

Also, says Eley, this revealed "some competing and conflicting parameters around what the customer was looking for".

Their post-sale review indicated they could have done more diligence on the third-party agency, its role, and on the entire process – and then ensured that the process followed actually matched the steps outlined in detail, he says.

"That's probably the only area. Maybe we could have triple-checked and consulted with a couple of other stakeholders just to make sure we fully understood," he says. "Also, maintaining and retaining dialogue with the end user customer, to understand what they're trying to achieve. I think in future we would seriously question an opportunity if it didn't allow that."

Eley also recalls one service provider that they started working with and then worked out it wasn't a good fit. Rushing into the deal optimistically "really didn't work out". Like Moyse, Eley recommends being "upfront and genuine" as key.

Christophe Malapris, sales director EMEA at email security provider Vade, confirms similar issues onboarding a European MSP with a sales team that seemed "really excited" about Vade’s products.

"We had a great relationship and helped them win their first deal. But their sales reps started sending us their prospects and we began to close all the deals for ourselves. At first it was great that they trusted us, and brought us a lot of business."

"After a while, it became too time-consuming for sales, presales and support teams. We had to think of a solution quickly to keep the customer happy while managing our own workloads," Malapris says.

The solution was to train the customer’s employees, which was a "major undertaking" even though it delivered the required results, enabling sales and marketing to reduce its dependence on Vade.

Research from McKinsey has shown B2B solutions sales can be prone to these kinds of issues, because many B2B solutions providers – such as IT VARs and MSPs – can be less commercially focused than transactional sales companies, such as box shifters and transactional resellers.

A more recent global study of 2,500 B2B companies highlights "insights, agility, talent and (in-house) tech" as key to superlative performance, suggesting the importance of human skills, supported by tech, to sales that deliver to customer needs.

"Outperforming B2Bs are more aggressive in making adaptations that put the customer first," the write-up notes. "Outperformers are 27% better at solution selling."

Fleur Doidge is a journalist with more than twenty years of experience, mainly writing features and news for B2B technology or business magazines and websites. She writes on a shifting assortment of topics, including the IT reseller channel, manufacturing, datacentre, cloud computing and communications. You can follow Fleur on Twitter.

Read more
Abstract big data picture spiral concept in blue on. black background
Navigating a shifting SMB channel partner paradigm
A glowing blue CGI representation of a network solution provided via the IT channel.
Why understanding the customer’s network unlocks its value and your success
Daniel Priestley on stage at ConnectWide IT Nation Connect
MSPs need to adopt a “more Rolex, less airline” approach to customer engagement
Business man running in between holes with red swirling arrow leading to the flag signifying the goal.
Seven pitfalls MSPs should avoid when building a resilient IT organization
Logo of VMware by Broadcom, developer of the VMware EXSi hypervisor, pictured on a black background at Mobile World Congress in Barcelona, Spain, on February 28, 2024.
A focused shift to partner-delivered services generates new opportunities with Broadcom
3D glass wavy background. Science fiction or information technology concept.
How the channel can simplify cybersecurity to build trust and agility for SMBs
Latest in Business
Digital handshake concept with Hand shake between two businessmen with digital hand
SYSPRO appoints Josef Al-Sibaie to spearhead global expansion
Matt Clifford speaking at Treasury Connect conference in 2023
Who is Matt Clifford?
Flexible work concept image showing woman working in office environment side by side with woman working from home.
IT professionals aren’t budging on flexible work demands – and more than half say they’ll quit if employers don’t meet expectations
Cybersecurity team members discussing strategy in an open plan office space, with male and female practitioners standing and others sitting at desks.
UK tech firms have a chance to trial a four-day week this year – here's how other pilot schemes fared
Cyber security concept image showing a digitized padlock sitting on a blue colored circuit board.
LevelBlue launches new partner program that’s “built for the future”
NHS logo displayed on a smartphone screen in white lettering on a blue background.
DHSC eyes infrastructure overhaul amid £114 million IT spending boost
Latest in Feature
Matt Clifford speaking at Treasury Connect conference in 2023
Who is Matt Clifford?
Open source vulnerabilities concept image showing HTML code on a computer screen.
Open source risks threaten all business users – it’s clear we must get a better understanding of open source software
An abstract CGI image of a large green cuboid being broken in half with yellow, orange, and red cubes to represent ransomware resilience and data encryption.
Building ransomware resilience to avoid paying out
The words "How effective are AI agents?" set against a dark blue background bearing the silhouettes of flowchart rectangles and diamonds to represent the computation and decisions made by AI agents. The words "AI agents" are yellow, while the others are white. The ITPro Podcast logo is in the bottom right-hand corner.
How effective are AI agents?
An illustration showing a mouth with speech bubbles and question marks and a stylized robot alien representing an AI assistant chirping away with symbols and ticks, to represent user annoyance with AI assistants.
On-device AI assistants are meant to be helpful – why do I find them so annoying?
A range of HP devices set on pedestals on the keynote stage at HP Amplify 2025 in Nashville, with a large screen in the background bearing the HP logo against a white background. The devices include AI PCs, laptops, and printers.
HP hones its edge AI ambitions at Amplify 2025