Linking to Playboy piracy isn't infringement, says EU advisor
Advocate general delivery advisory ahead of landmark case


Linked to pirated content online cannot be seen as copyright infringement, the EU advocate general has advised.
Melchior Wathelet, a top legal advisor within the EU Court of Justice, has said that posting hyperlinks to copyrighted content hosted by a third party cannot in itself constitute an infringement.
The decision comes after an ongoing legal battle betweLinking to pen Dutch website GeenStijl.nl and the publisher of Playboy.
The site linked to a series of leaked photos, hosted on file-sharing service FileFactory, but when Playboy publisher Sanoma had the pictures removed from FileFactory, GeenStijl simply linked to another source.
The EU Court of Justice now has to rule on whether or not these hyperlinks are a "communication to the public" and therefore an infringement of copyright.
In his advisory, advocate general Wathelet said that "the posting of the hyperlinks in the main proceedings does not, in my view, constitute a 'communication to the public'".
He also added that any other interpretation "would significantly impair the functioning of the Internet and undermine one of the main objectives of Directive 2001/29, namely the development of the information society in Europe."
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Wathelet's decision is not legally binding, and the court will still have to reach its own consensus on the case. However, the advocate general's advice often informs the court's decisions in these matters.
The case is a landmark one, and could "distort the fair balance of rights and interests between the different categories of rightholders", according to Wathelet. "In my view," he said, "such interference in the functioning of the internet must be avoided."
Adam Shepherd has been a technology journalist since 2015, covering everything from cloud storage and security, to smartphones and servers. Over the course of his career, he’s seen the spread of 5G, the growing ubiquity of wireless devices, and the start of the connected revolution. He’s also been to more trade shows and technology conferences than he cares to count.
Adam is an avid follower of the latest hardware innovations, and he is never happier than when tinkering with complex network configurations, or exploring a new Linux distro. He was also previously a co-host on the ITPro Podcast, where he was often found ranting about his love of strange gadgets, his disdain for Windows Mobile, and everything in between.
You can find Adam tweeting about enterprise technology (or more often bad jokes) @AdamShepherUK.
-
GCHQ’s mass data collection practices breached human rights law, European court rules
News Surveillance methods disclosed by Edward Snowden in 2013 ruled illegal in landmark ruling
By Keumars Afifi-Sabet
-
Google and Microsoft agree to crack down on piracy
News Tech firms sign up to voluntary code of conduct
By Clare Hopping
-
Swedish ISPs cannot be forced to block The Pirate Bay
News Swedish court rules that ISPs cannot be legally compelled to block file-sharing sites on the grounds of copyright infringement
By Adam Shepherd
-
Online pirates could face same prison term as sex offenders
In-depth Harsher penalties for online piracy are 'not appropriate', warns paralegal
By Jane McCallion
-
Why ISPs are blocking ebook piracy sites
News Publishers Association wins piracy site ban after millions of takedown requests
By Nicole Kobie
-
BBC says ISPs should cut off pirate connections
News BBC Worldwide thinks those who repeatedly infringe copyright should not have an internet connection at all
By Clare Hopping
-
Megaupload founder denied access to evidence by NZ Court of Appeal
News Kim Dotcom to take his fight to the Supreme Court.
By Khidr Suleman
-
UK court orders blocking of more torrent websites
News H33T, Fenopy and Kickass Torrents get blocked
By Rene Millman