Judge blocks Florida's social media law
The bill is "riddled with imprecision and ambiguity"


Just one day before a controversial anti-big-tech bill was due to become law in Florida, a federal judge has blocked it as unconstitutional.
The bill, SB 7072, was due to come into effect today. However, federal district court judge Robert Hinkle granted a preliminary injunction against it on Wednesday, arguing it was likely to contravene the First Amendment right to freedom of speech.
The bill banned internet companies from suspending political candidates' accounts, imposing penalties of up to $250,000 per day for violations. It also stopped social media platforms from prioritizing the visibility of posts in ways that it saw as unfair.
The only exceptions to these rules were firms that also owned theme parks.
Technology advocacy groups criticized the law, calling it unconstitutional. Technology industry associations NetChoice and the Computer and Communications Industry Association sued the state immediately after Governor Ron DeSantis signed the bill in May.
In his opinion granting the injunction, Hinkle warned that the legislation "compels providers to host speech that violates their standards - speech they otherwise would not host - and forbids providers from speaking as they otherwise would."
He added that stopping a company from deplatforming a candidate in good faith based on objectionable content contravenes Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, echoing concerns bought by the plaintiffs.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Hinkle criticized the bill for failing to define many terms or defining them too broadly, calling it "riddled with imprecision and ambiguity."
For example, its definition of political candidates set "a low bar," Hinkle said, while its definition of "journalistic enterprise" could include a large retailer but exclude a small newspaper.
Disney, which operates in theme parks in Florida and would have been exempt from SB 7072, didn't get off the hook either. Hinkle said the definition of social media provider applied to companies "smaller than the providers covered by the statutes and those under common ownership with a large theme park."
"The legislation now at issue was an effort to rein in social-media providers deemed too large and too liberal," the opinion concluded. "Balancing the exchange of ideas among private speakers is not a legitimate governmental interest."
Danny Bradbury has been a print journalist specialising in technology since 1989 and a freelance writer since 1994. He has written for national publications on both sides of the Atlantic and has won awards for his investigative cybersecurity journalism work and his arts and culture writing.
Danny writes about many different technology issues for audiences ranging from consumers through to software developers and CIOs. He also ghostwrites articles for many C-suite business executives in the technology sector and has worked as a presenter for multiple webinars and podcasts.
-
Asus ZenScreen Fold OLED MQ17QH review
Reviews A stunning foldable 17.3in OLED display – but it's too expensive to be anything more than a thrilling tech demo
By Sasha Muller
-
How the UK MoJ achieved secure networks for prisons and offices with Palo Alto Networks
Case study Adopting zero trust is a necessity when your own users are trying to launch cyber attacks
By Rory Bathgate
-
Starmer bets big on AI to unlock public sector savings
News AI adoption could be a major boon for the UK and save taxpayers billions, according to prime minister Keir Starmer.
By George Fitzmaurice
-
UK government targets ‘startup’ mindset in AI funding overhaul
News Public sector AI funding will be overhauled in the UK in a bid to simplify processes and push more projects into development.
By George Fitzmaurice
-
UK government signs up Anthropic to improve public services
News The UK government has signed a memorandum of understanding with Anthropic to explore how the company's Claude AI assistant could be used to improve access to public services.
By Emma Woollacott
-
The UK’s AI ambitions face one major hurdle – finding enough home-grown talent
News Research shows UK enterprises are struggling to fill AI roles, raising concerns over the country's ability to meet expectations in the global AI race.
By Emma Woollacott
-
US government urged to overhaul outdated technology
News A review from the US Government Accountability Office (GAO) has found legacy technology and outdated IT systems are negatively impacting efficiency.
By George Fitzmaurice
-
Government urged to improve tech procurement practices
News The National Audit Office highlighted wasted money and a lack of progress on major digital transformation programmes
By Emma Woollacott
-
Government says new data bill will free up millions of hours of public sector time
News The UK government is proposing new data laws it says could free up millions of hours of police and NHS time every year and boost the UK economy by £10 billion.
By Emma Woollacott
-
Online Safety Act slammed by rights groups as bill gains royal assent
News The Online Safety Act has been described as a veiled attempt to secure access to encrypted messages
By Rory Bathgate